This game is one of my kids' favorites! It looks intimidating, but it's super easy once you understand the idea. Give it a try and let me know what you think. Should I post other songs?
To prepare the game:
1. Download the PDF at the bottom of the page.
2. Print the first two pages
3. Print the third and forth pages on the back of the first two.
4. Cut out the strips.
Now you should have a puzzle with the picture on one side and the lyrics to the song on the other. Cut a piece of clear shelf paper big enough to cover the entire puzzle. Remove the backing and attach it to the blackboard, sticky-side-out, with magnets or tape. Note: an anonymous commenter left the suggestion to use press-and-seal kitchen paper so the puzzle lasts for multiple uses. Y'all are geniuses! (I wish I could get that stuff in Holland!) Attach the puzzle pieces, lyrics-side-out, to the blackboard with magnets or clear tape.
Tell the children that they need to learn the song so well that they can recite it inside-out, backward and forward. They're going to see if they can sing the song from the end to the beginning. Take the strip that reads "Yes, I know Heavenly Father loves me." and place it at the bottom of the piece of shelf paper. Explain that this is the last line of the song.
Continue the game until all the word strips are on the page in the correct order. When the lyrics are complete, remove the magnets holding up the shelf paper and turn it around, showing the children the picture side of the puzzle.
Note: In the interest of time, you may need to sing each verse separately (second verse first). Alternately, you may ask the children to listen for the previous TWO word strips. This is often too difficult for the children at the beginning of the game, but it is much easier when half of the word strips are already gone.
The original image, "Creation-Living Creatures" is borrowed from the LDS Media Library.